By Kalpana Kannabiran
Reviewer for Biblio: A Review of Books
New Delhi, India

“is it possible to forget the past? And if so, is forgetting the healthiest course?” 

A powerful testimony of child sexual abuse, Father’s Touch approaches the difficult question of sexual violence in all its complexity. The different layers in which violence is embedded and the indispensability of the painful exercise of peeling off each layer in order to “see” and cope with the impact; the different layers to which the impact of violence penetrates and the gradual realization that the fields of violence and its impact need not be coterminus, that impacts can spin off in completely different, unanticipated directions; the different layers through which memory must plough, in order to capture the full meaning of the experience of violence – make survival and recovery a daunting task: “I have recollections of events, of dreams that never lie, of written evidence that the past did indeed occurAt times these flashbacks paralyze, shock, frighten, or sadden me. Sometimes they make me laughThe world surrounding me assumes any public disclosure translates into a personal reality. However, in my case nothing could be further from the truth. The more I speak or write about my family history, the more unreal it becomes. Any listener or reader of my words would probably experience an emotional response to my story that I can only envy.” [p. 1]

Subjected to sexual abuse since the age of 3 ½ by a father who abused all his four children, three boys and a girl, and his wife, Donald travels in his account, from believing that “[h]ome is where I am loved and accepted. Mama hugs and talks to me. Papa plays The Game with me. Home is normal to me” [p.49], to reflecting on this “normalcy”: “I don’t know how I came to understand that it was wrong and that I had been changed as a result of The Game when I had never talked about it with anyone.” [p. 52].

If comprehension is the first step in dealing with abuse, coping is the next, since it is rarely possible for victims to remove themselves immediately from an abusive situation. The most painful part of abuse then, is the period when the victim knows s/he is being abused and continues to experience it because there is no instant road to freedom. The difference in impact of the same cycles of violence by the same perpetrator on the different people who experience it is startling, and yet the narration places incontrovertibly before us the entire continuum of traumatic disorder that must result from the practice of violence especially within the patriarchal family: Dissociation or the simultaneous existence of different selves and the firm separation in consciousness of the experiential self from the intellectual one at one end, an aggressive, ironically insensitive authoritarianism on the other end, obesity, nagging interpersonal difficulties, kleptomania, non performance at school and a complete and almost irretrievable erasure of the self between the two extremes. 

By isolating the wife and children from any social circle, by seeking the support and sanction of religious elders in the community for this control, either actively through the preaching of ideologies of forgiveness, or passively through silence and/or inaction, by drawing support from the justice delivery system just by virtue of being a man [evident here in the complete disconnection between the divorce proceedings and testimonies of abuse rendered during those proceedings] in short through the interweaving of domestic violence with sexual assault, and the total legitimate control – mental and physical – that the perpetrator has over his entire family, he uncovers for us the nuts and bolts of patriarchal systems. Small wonder then that the author Donald D’Haene asks “How can I not be a feminist?” [Personal communication].

The first way of dealing with abuse, they say, is to “speak out”: disclosure as a one time, one shot blowing the lid off abuse, because the law will take charge the moment we speak. Father’s Touch teaches us that disclosure is as multi-layered and multi textured as the violence itself, and the “law” [assuming of course that by that term we mean a secular law] hangs above, barely touching the surface, and even that reluctantly. We learn that the law also “copes” with family violence through dissociation, providing in the process little relief or opportunity for recuperation to survivors! In Donald’s case, the first disclosure was to his mother when he was ten, i.e., six and a half years after he began to be abused. The earliest disclosure outside the immediate family was soon after, when his older brother Ronnie told a doctor. The doctor replied: “You’re probably going to turn into a homosexual. Just be careful and don’t turn into a molester. It happens quite frequently,” and sent him home with his abuser and did nothing further.” [p.78]. Then Ronnie confides in the Elders of the religious community. “Their reaction: a mix of detachment, curiosity, and confirmation.” [pp.105-106]. Over a period of nine years approximately thirty people had been told about the abuse, including policemen, judges, attorneys, physicians and the Church Elders. And yet, when the survivors decided to press charges of assault, the Crown Attorney failed miserably in framing the charges accurately. 

Through this entire period however, the dogged pursuit of stability was possible because of the conviction that freedom is not impossible to find, and the determination to find it: “We are united on a mission: we want our mother free of her jailor. Her liberation from captivity takes on more importance than our own freedom. The roles of parent and child are forever reversed. At fifteen, I am counselor, caretaker, therapist, and tower of strength for my mother who is forty-oneSo in 1976, it was Ronny and I, at the ages of 18 and 15, who convinced our mother to leave her tormentor and who sought out temporary lodging for the five of us” [p. 144]. 

There are larger questions that must be addressed in the course of growing up. How do we forge a secular community of support? What expectations do we place on it? What are the ways in which we can negotiate with the different individuals in this community without undermining our self-esteem? How do we begin to reckon with our own sexuality and sexual orientation in positive terms, not binding them down to the sexual abuse/assault, so far our only knowledge of sex. How can we carve out a space for spirituality and belief within this community, while recognizing that even religion can falter? In Donald’s words, “will any of us find god, love and peace?” [p.188]

There are three levels of narration in the book – chronologically, and three levels of reflection. The narration of the journey through childhood and into adulthood to Maurice is the primary one. Within this, the recounting of that journey with therapist, Wilf and the reflection on sessions with Wilf. This book foregrounds the fact that anyone concerned with the impact of violence, must think through the critical issues of recovery and the return of faith. And both of these are only possible through disclosure, the courage of conviction, the creation of a community of support, and criminal prosecution -- a will to act simultaneously and with determination on the home and the world, radically transforming both in the process.

An amazing and deeply moving testimony of survival, faith and courage, Father's Touch reinscribes in positive, empowering ways, the meaning of human relationships and social responsibility.

 
Kalpana Kannabiran
Reviewer for Biblio: A Review of Books, 
Co-author, De-Eroticizing Assault: Essays on Modesty, Honour and Power, Calcutta: Stree, 2002.
Associate Professor, NALSAR University of Law, Hyderabad
Asmita Resource Centre for Women, Secunderabad
New Delhi, India

tramadol order overnight saturday delivery career in pharmacy buy tramadol teenage tramadol abuse drinking alcohol with tramadol tramadol in dogs aclepsa tramadol cheap tramadol without prescription buy tramadol online overnight delivery cod how to get off tramadol purpose of tramadol hcl50 mg tramadol prescriptions delivered cod cheap tramadol can tramadol pills be split bay tramadol mexico online tramadol tramadol cheap free overnight shipping side effects tramadol cheapest tramadol order tramadol online no prescription money order tramadol tramadol neuropathic pregabalin tramadol overnight tramadol addiction tramadol adiction tramadol dependence dosage for tramadol tramadol withdraw tramadol drug interactions addiction to tramadol pet meds tramadol 50mg potentiate tramadol 200mg tramadol order tramadol no prescription tramadol abuse addictive nature of tramadol tramadol helps withdrawal chemical make up of tramadol drug info on tramadol hcl 50mg tab tramadol advil dystonia and tramadol tramadol opiates barbituates tramadol and wellbutrin tramadol sales tramadol fast saturday tramadol and interactions with other drugs tramadol cod withdrawl from tramadol tramadol dog buy tramadol without precription tramadol for pets drug store cost for tramadol tramadol hcl 50 mg tablets tramadol tramadol bp 180 tramadol cheap taking tramadol while pregnant tramadol oxycodone combination effects help with tramadol withdrawal cheapest tramadol available online without persciption buy online tramadol tramadol hydrochloride content cheap tramadol prescriptions online career in pharmacy tramadol tramadol delivery all 50 states compare tramadol prices difference between ultram and tramadol 377 tramadol ultram tramadol cod cheap tramadol overnight delivery order no prescription tramadol online nextday tramadol side effects of tramadol hydrochloride buy tramadol with no prescription tramadol next day air mutual tramadol tramadol overnight 50 states tramadol and dogs order tramadol online 180 tramadol mercial mortgage broker buy tramadol tramadol hcl tabs tramadol vs percocet buy tramadol sweden buy cheap tramadol tramadol drug is irritability a side effect of tramadol cod tramadol cheap tramadol fedex overnight information tramadol weight loss pill no fax payday loan buy tramadol vet meds tramadol high on tramadol tramadol 240ct overnight delivery if ordered by 4 00pm purchase 100mg tramadol online indication of tramadol best television set buy tramadol tramadol onlinetramadol online tramadol timed release tramadol hci cheapest tramadol available online cod tramadol money orders tramadol without prescription quick withdrawl from tramadol tramadol dosing in dogs tramadol ultram tramadol money order tramadol no prescription florida tramadol uses tramadol 24 7 7 days a week no script overnight how to get high on tramadol order tramadol tramadol hcl is tramadol scheduled tramadol and celexa filing income tax buy tramadol tramadol information tramadol class 3 drug tramadol side effects depression fatigue tramadol pharmacology cheap tramadol without a prior prescription tramadol generic what is tramadol hcl tramadol 120 tablets tramadol fed priority overnight tramadol cat medication tramadol shipped to florida cod online tramadol cod overnight cod tramadol tramadol doses tramadol hcl 50mg tab tramadol description tramadol florida tramadol cash on delivery buy tramadol overnight tramadol use in canines tramadol without a prescription how long does it take tramadol to leave the system tramadol saturday effects of snorting tramadol tramadol puchase tramadol cod imitrex diet pill tramadol medication tramadol addiction treatment buy tramadol without a prescription vioxx lawyer buy now tramadol cheal tramadol overnight tramadol maintence buy tramadol online overnight tramadol saturday delivery does tramadol have codeine tramadol or lortab tramadol withdrawl tramadol generic ultram cheap tramadol cod tramadol buzz tramadol cheap tramadol 50mg tramadol free shipping tramadol withdrawal tramadol 100 tramadol saturday delivery free tramadol tramadol priority fedex pet meds tramadol what is tramadol used for what is tramadol hcl50mg tramadol more addicting than vicodin buy tramadol cod canada tramadol no prescription buy tramadol free shipping tramadol habit forming buy domain online 199mb com tramadol tramadol no prior rx needed cheapest cod money order tramadol florida tramadol delivery tramadol no rx tramadol 377 tramadol hydrochloride uses tramadol free overnight shipping 180 pills no rx overnight tramadol tramadol imprints tramadol cheap no rx tramadol side effects robaxin tramadol together picture of tramadol ingredients in tramadol tramadol treats withdrawal symptoms tramadol hydrichloride tramadol no prescription required tramadol hcl effects career in pharmacy buy now tramadol tramadol prescription tramadol crystal meth no fax payday loan tramadol animal medicine tramadol atkins diet menu buy tramadol what is tramadol what is the street value for tramadol dog tramadol tramadol online cod how long does tramadol sleeplessness during withdrawal last tramadol effectiveness overnight tramadol saturday tramadol for dogs tramadol doses for dogs tramadol overdose in dogs will tramadol hcl test positive in drug testing high quality tramadol tramadol prescription drug ultram side effects what is tramadol hcl 50mg fast tramadol tramadol no prescription tramadol hcl 50mg mt7 tramadol 50mg dollars tramadol for vicodin detox message boards will tramadol show up in a drug test tramadol hcl 50 mg tab no prescription tramadol tramadol 50 mg buy tramadol at a cheap price online international tramadol no prescription tramadol free fedex cheap no rx tramadol failed drug testbuy tramadol cheap no rx free overnight shipping tramadol cheap free fedex overnight tramadol detox side effects purchase tramadol tramadol totse buy tramadol in panama tramadol without perscription can you take 2 50 mg tramadol buy tramadol lowest tramadol saturday delivery available what mg does tramadol come in using tramadol for withdrawals cheap fioricet soma tramadol viagra ingredients of tramadol canine tramadol ultram or tramadol and drug testing tramadol hydrochloride cheap tramadol without perscription tramadol 100mg tramadol dosing side effects of tramadol tramadol injection tramadol for sale without a presription next day shipping tramadol what is tramadol 50 mg taken for hoodia diet pill buy tramadol now adult add and tramadol saturday tramadol delivery cheap cod money order tramadol pharmacy tech reer tramadol 100 tramadol can tramadol be taking while brestfeeding canine tramadol dosage use of tramadol in dogs tramadol 180 tramadol for dogs side effects where to find tramadol pain releiver tramadol hcl 50mg tramadol ketorolac tramadol hcl 50 mg tramadol info commercial mortgage broker buy tramadol tramadol drug concerns cheap genaric tramadol with no prescription tramadol shipped cod order tramadol online pharnacy hydrocodone vs tramadol tramadol cod delivery tramadol canine tramadol bulk prices cheap book buy celeste com guest site tramadol long term effects of tramadol tramadol purchase tramadol dogs tramadol fed ex 180 cod tramadol and lactation tramadol fed ex 180 cash on delivery ups tramadol tramadol 180 tablets tramadol doseage can tramadol be given to women breast feeding tramadol er chewing tramadol potentiate tramadol effects side effects of the drug tramadol high dose tramadol experience tramadol half life tramadol dosage about tramadol wellbutrin tramadol dosage for tramadol for dogs tramadol cheap no rx free from india tramadol side effects feline pet tramadol free fedex no rx tramadol effective dose tramadol ups tramadol for coming off of opiates buy tramadol buy tramadol online cod generic tramadol snorting tramadol tramadol drug forums soma tramadol fioricet tramadol side effects with heart meds get tramadol out of urine effect of tramadol on the lungs drug information facts about tramadol false positive pcp tramadol tramadol and nsaids for dogs tramadol pictures tramadol without prescriptions buy tramadol with overnight and saturday delivery health solutions network tramadol buy online tramadol withdrawal symptoms tramadol express delivery tramadol without a perscription tramadol how supplied 50mg tramadol pill tramadol no prescription fed ex priority what is the pill tramadol cheap tramadol cod free fedex is tramadol an opiate counseling degree online tramadol tramadol out of urine test ultram pain management in dogs using tramadol tramadol hcl compared to lortab hsn tramadol drugs made from tramadol can you inject ultram tramadol 100mg tramadol tramadol drug test can a drug screen show tramadol order tramadol online consultation is tramadol a narcotic tramadol effects does tramadol show in a drug test tramadol high tramadol overnight delivery tramadol online comparing tramadol to lortab tramadol cod florida tramadol maintenance tramadol study free saturday delivery tramadol tramadol overdose tramadol 50mg and blood clots tramadol hydrochloride for dogs